Thursday, June 3, 2010

Ban The Burn, or Burn the Ban?

As a Libertarian and a Veteran, when it comes to the issue of making flag-burning a crime, or an act which would justify shooting someone, I am a Constitutionalist -- a First Amendment Constitutionalist. You are entitled to your opinion about what it stands for, and entitled to say what you think, in words or other symbols. The Flag is not itself any of the things it represents, nor some kind of sacred relic, but is an icon, a symbol, a word. Flying it, folding it, and flaming it up are all statements using that symbol. To declare it cannot be used to make non-positive statements in opposition to political power is the same kind of thinking as Muslims believing a cartoon showing their idol as being something less than God justifies acts of violence. It is simply bad thought control, the opposite of freedom. Burning someone else's flag (made in China, $15) is a property violation, but that is not what is at issue here. To make it illegal for anyone to burn a flag he has bought as a political statement is to truly tarnish the principle of free expression it stands for.

Here is an article in some depth on this, first published about '97 or so, I think.

Is Flag Burning A Crime?

2 comments:

  1. Personally, I think burning our flag is a no-class act. But, if you want to burn a picture of your ex-wife, hey, light her up! But I will go a step further. I was given a little flag (American) by the guys at the "Reading of Names" at our California Vietnam Veteran Memorial last weekend. I have placed it on the front of my Chicken Prison on my farm. I like it. It fits well there and my cats like it, too. So, if someone burns it, I will shoot them in the stomach. Catch my drift?

    LT Bobby Ross

    ReplyDelete
  2. I fought for the right for individuals to be able to burn the flag or hang it upside down for a sign of emergency/distress (my preferred route). And I agree that individuals deserve this right. In the same token I believe that I have a right to defend my flag "for which it stands", and have to take that flag from you and properly dispose of it.

    ReplyDelete